10 greatest Premier League players that never won the FA Cup

Greatest players never to win the FA Cup |Imago

10 greatest Premier League players that never won the FA Cup

Ayoola Kelechi 23:51 - 25.01.2024

Most players who play in England dream of winning the FA Cup but only a few get to realise this dream

The FA Cup, steeped in history and prestige, has been an unattainable dream for some of the Premier League's most renowned players. 

So who are the most notable players who never achieved success with England’s oldest trophy, and what were their near-misses with FA Cup glory?

Rio Ferdinand

Rio Ferdinand's absence from the FA Cup honors list is particularly striking given his achievements. At Manchester United, Ferdinand established himself as one of the world's best defenders, winning numerous Premier League titles and the UEFA Champions League. 

Manchester United icon Rio Ferdinand | Imago
Manchester United icon Rio Ferdinand | Imago

His suspension during the 2003-04 FA Cup season was a significant personal and professional setback, marking a bittersweet chapter in his otherwise illustrious career.

Nemanja Vidic

Nemanja Vidic's tale is similar to Ferdinand's. As Ferdinand's central defensive partner, Vidic was instrumental in Manchester United's domestic and European successes. 

Nemanja Vidic was the Premier League Player of the Month for January 2009 (IMAGO)
Nemanja Vidic was the Premier League Player of the Month for January 2009 (IMAGO)

His physicality and defensive prowess were hallmarks of United's play, yet the FA Cup remained just beyond his reach, highlighting the unpredictable nature of this historic competition.

Emmanuel Adebayor

Emmanuel Adebayor's journey across several top Premier League clubs, including Arsenal, Manchester City, and Tottenham, is a testament to his quality as a forward. 

Emmanuel Adebayor celebrates in Arsenal colours | Imago
Emmanuel Adebayor celebrates in Arsenal colours | Imago

His closest encounter with FA Cup success, ironically, came with Crystal Palace, a team not typically associated with footballing silverware. This exemplifies the FA Cup's unique ability to create unexpected narratives and underdog stories.

Harry Kane

Harry Kane's story in the FA Cup encapsulates the individual challenges faced by top players in securing team accolades. Despite his personal achievements and goal-scoring records at Tottenham, team success, particularly in the FA Cup, has eluded him. 

Tottenham all time highest goal scorer, Harry Kane Photo Credit || Imago
Tottenham all time highest goal scorer, Harry Kane Photo Credit || Imago

This underscores the idea that individual brilliance, while crucial, is not always sufficient to secure team trophies.

Alan Shearer

Alan Shearer's narrative in the FA Cup is a poignant reminder of the fine margins in football. As the Premier League's top scorer, his inability to win the FA Cup with Newcastle United, despite coming close, emphasies the unpredictable and often cruel nature of cup competitions. 

Alan Shearer – The Premier League's Ultimate Striker | Imago
Alan Shearer – The Premier League's Ultimate Striker | Imago

His journey underscores the notion that success in football is not just about talent but also timing and circumstance.

Edwin van der Sar

Edwin van der Sar's FA Cup miss is notable given his extensive trophy cabinet. His career, dotted with major trophies like the UEFA Champions League and numerous league titles, demonstrates how even the most decorated players can find certain competitions elusive. 

Edwin van der Sar - "The Dutch Giant" | Imago
Edwin van der Sar - "The Dutch Giant" | Imago

His story in the context of the FA Cup speaks to the unique challenges and uncertainties inherent in knockout football.

Georginio Wijnaldum

Georginio Wijnaldum's departure from Liverpool a year before their FA Cup triumph is a classic example of football's unpredictability. A key player in Liverpool's recent resurgence, his contributions to their Premier League and Champions League victories were significant. However, his move away from Liverpool before their FA Cup win adds a layer of 'what if' to his career narrative.

Waving goodbye: Georginio Wijnaldum played his final game for Liverpool in Sunday's 2-0 win over Crystal Palace
Waving goodbye: Georginio Wijnaldum played his final game for Liverpool in Sunday's 2-0 win over Crystal Palace

Georginio Wijnaldum's departure from Liverpool a year before their FA Cup triumph is a classic example of football's unpredictability. A key player in Liverpool's recent resurgence, his contributions to their Premier League and Champions League victories were significant. However, his move away from Liverpool before their FA Cup win adds a layer of 'what if' to his career narrative.

Diego Costa

Diego Costa's time at Chelsea was marked by success and controversy. His aggressive style and goal-scoring prowess helped Chelsea to multiple league titles. However, the FA Cup's absence from his list of achievements illustrates the competition's competitive nature and the difficulty of winning multiple trophies across different competitions.

Diego Costa won the Premier League with Chelsea in the 2016-17 season | Credit: IMAGO
Diego Costa won the Premier League with Chelsea in the 2016-17 season | Credit: IMAGO

The stories of these players illustrate the FA Cup's unique place in English football. It stands as a testament to the sport's unpredictability and the challenges even the most skilled players face in their quest for glory. These narratives, woven into the fabric of the Premier League and the FA Cup, enrich the sport's history and remind us of the myriad paths a footballing career can take.

Related content